Is Your Book Clean or Moral?

by Ane Mulligan  @AneMulligan

On a writer’s loop, a recent topic raised some interesting comments. The question? Should our work be clean or moral? Well, yes … depending.

I don’t mean to be ambiguous … or maybe I do. I think the answer depends on what God has called you to do.

Some Christian authors write from a Christian worldview to entertain. Some write specifically to show the way to Christ. Both are good and both are needed.

First: Clean is a story without bad language, sex scenes, or gratuitous violence. Moral delivers a message concerned with the principles of right and wrong and the goodness or badness of human character.

You can’t force what God hasn’t called you to write. I know … I tried—not once but twice—and ended up deleting 30K words the first time and 40K the second. I also tried to write a devotional book. I got the idea to create one for the actors. It started with me complimenting an actor. Their response was lip service about it wasn’t them but God. Hogwash, I say. God gave you the talent, but you had to learn the lines. Just say, “Thank you,” and give God the glory in your heart. Anyway, I wrote that devotion and two others. Then the well ran dry. Obviously, God did not call me to be a devotion writer. I contributed what little I had there to a book and that was that.

Don’t feel defensive if you’re called to entertain. Christians need to be entertained without being subjected to bedroom scenes or graphic horror. Kristin Billerbeck was highly popular with the missionary world, since they were in the world and not in the protective walls of the church. Those books were what they called chick-lit.

Ronie Kendig writes romantic suspense with gritty, raw characters in action-packed stories. Her brand is rapid-fire fiction. She’s a multi award-winning bestseller—without sex or gratuitous violence. Yet, another author I know writes conversion scenes in every book, and those scenes are organic to the story, never forced or heavy-handed. She’s called to write her books to show the way to salvation in Christ.

In my first published novel, my main character was a newer Christian. She didn’t have it right yet, and she often misquoted or misunderstood scripture. It led to some humorous moments, which most of my readers loved. Yet one didn’t. In a review, one reader said I had “vague and inaccurate scripture references.” The funny part is I didn’t … but my main character did. That reader wanted a sermon in a book—not real life.

Here’s the deal. Christians sin. We get things wrong. We lash out in anger. All things we later regret and take with a broken heart to our Father. But, as He reminded me recently, “Nothing can separate us from the Father’s love.” Not if we are His children.

If God has called you to write a work of fiction that shows the way to Christ, do it without a heavy hand. You still want to be entertaining. A very wise woman once told me, “People let down their guard when they think they’re being entertained. Then, when they least expect it, our words reach out, touch hearts, and change lives.”

However you write, to whomever you write, let your creativity follow the path God has laid out for you. If you do that, your words will change lives.

 

Ane Mulligan has been a voracious reader ever since her mom instilled within her a love of reading at age three, escaping into worlds otherwise unknown. But when Ane saw PETER PAN on stage, she was struck with a fever from which she never recovered—stage fever. And so, by night, she’s CEO of a community theatre company and by day, a bestselling, award-winning novelist. She lives in Sugar Hill, GA, with her artist husband and a rascally Rottweiler. Find Ane on her website, Amazon Author page, Facebook, Instagram, Pinterest, and The Write Conversation.

The Conversation

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

4 Comments

    The Conversation

  1. Barbara Harper says:

    I agree. I read a wide variety of Christian fiction, and I’ve appreciated clear and natural salvation stories as well as more subtle references. I especially appreciated the former when my mom was alive. She wasn’t a Christian and didn’t want to talk about having a relationship with the Lord. But she would read anything I sent her and loved Dee Henderson and Terri Blackstock. I was so thankful those ladies presented characters coming to Christ in a way that was understandable to someone who didn’t grow up in church. I never heard my mom share a testimony of coming to the Lord before she died, but I have reasons to hope she did come to believe due to changes in her thinking over her last several years.

    But I am also a stickler for accuracy in presenting God’s truth so we don’t mislead people about what He said. An unbeliever or immature Christian reader wouldn’t be able to tell whether a Scripture is misquoted or whether a character’s application is wrong unless that is brought out in the story. That can be done without a sermon, perhaps by another character smiling over the mistake or gently correcting it, or the main character coming to realize where she was wrong later in the story.

  2. Melody Morrison says:

    Great clarity, Ane. Thank you for differentiating so well.

  3. Susan Sams Baggott says:

    Thank you for this wonderful article. I write “letters to my 30 something worldly children”. Therefore, if I preach they won’t read it. If I make them laugh or cry or cringe or say, “yep, working on it, Mom,” then I know I’m writing the way God calls me to write.

  4. Jay Heavner says:

    Interesting. I see your point of view. It’s also interesting how the Bible has within its pages some bad language, sex scenes, or gratuitous violence. Just something to think about.